About

Read to Resist: Weeks 18 & 19

We at C&R and at Pangea World Theater believe that cultural resistance to the profound violence around us (economic, military, racial, sexual etc) is imperative. Context, analysis and critical thinking are key elements to resisting injustice, as is the art that inspires, delights and pushes us towards empathy and the creation of more humane and sustainable models for our communities and environment.

We at C&R and at Pangea World Theater believe that cultural resistance to the profound violence around us (economic, military, racial, sexual etc) is imperative. Context, analysis and critical thinking are key elements to resisting injustice, as is the art that inspires, delights  and pushes us towards empathy and the creation of more humane and sustainable models for our communities and environment. Read to Resist is a curated bi-weekly reading/ viewing/ listening list to give us some of that context and inspiration. So whether you’re sheltering in place or marching in the streets; creating art or teaching;  parenting or healing, we urge you to read up and spread knowledge and solidarity to those around you.  

-C&R

Zadie Smith On Her New Essay Collection, ‘Intimations’ A thoughtful conversation with novelist and essayist Zadie Smith on her latest work, touching on race, Covid, and writing. 

Outbreak at San Quentin A moving radio investigation of how the pandemic raging inside the walls of San Quentin is affecting those incarcerated there and their families. 

Opinion | Look to Local Prosecutors for Police Reform Progressive San Francisco DA Chesa Boudin discusses a possible route to meaningful reform of police departments.

Urban planning as a tool of white supremacy – the other lesson from Minneapolis A look at the lessons Minneapolis can teach about the connections between urban planning and racism.

‘The Sustenance of Loneliness’: An Interview with David Adjmi Writer David Adjmi talks about “loneliness as a source of artistic attunement”

Body Meets World | On the Media On the Media explores how “this wouldn’t be the first time the built world has adapted to the spread of infectious disease.”

Before Portland, Trump’s Shock Troops Went After Border Activists The Intercept reports on how the purported threat of antifa was long used to justify militarized targeting of immigration activists and how it is now being used against protesters in Portland.

Opinion | Colonialism Made the Modern World. Let’s Remake It. This NY Times opinion piece delves into the shadow cast by colonialism on today’s world and what we can do about it.

First the Nat’l Security State Surged Baghdad, now it is Surging Portland and Seattle Historian Juan Cole traces the recent “surge” of federal agents in American cities to previous “surges” of American power in occupied Baghdad.

Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police Force An examination of the warning signs that Homeland Security was a secret police force waiting to happen.

Trump has helped the US to see its dark side. It will still be there when he goes | Nesrine Malik A reflection on why Trump is not an anomaly but rather an egregious manifestation of the white supremacism at the heart of the American project. 

Summary executions and widespread repression under Bolivia’s interim government reports rights advocates from Harvard and University Network for Human Rights A report on the brutal aftermath of the US backed coup against democratically elected socialist government of Evo Morales in Bolivia.

Walcott in New York | by Caryl Phillips A look at the formative New York moments of poet and playwright Derek Walcott..

Read to Resist: Weeks 16 & 17

Whether you’re sheltering in place or marching in the streets; creating art or teaching; parenting or healing, we urge you to read up and spread knowledge and solidarity to those around you.

This section of Call & Response started as Read in Place, a weekly (or bi weekly) reading list to inform and inspire through the months of shelter in place as the Coronavirus shook our world. While the virus has not gone away yet (socially distance and wear your masks, folks!) it has also exposed something that has long been with us: the inequality and systemic violence and discrimination rampant in the U.S. and beyond. And with the massive protests resulting from the murder by of George Floyd, and the state repression that followed nationwide, it is clear we are entering a key moment as an anti-racist uprising and a deadly pandemic coincide. So Read in Place will henceforth be known as Read to Resist. That is because we believe cultural resistance to the profound violence around us (economic, military, racial, sexual etc) is imperative. Context, analysis and critical thinking are key elements to resisting injustice, as is art that inspires, delights  and pushes us towards empathy and the creation of new, more humane and sustainable models for our communities and environment. So whether you’re sheltering in place or marching in the streets; creating art or teaching;  parenting or healing, we urge you to read up and spread knowledge and solidarity to those around you.  

-C&R

The Empire of All Maladies | Nick Estes A reflection on colonial contagions and indigenous resistance.

The existing order of things A report on the war on the poor being waged by South Africa’s ruling class. 

Police and the Wealth of Nations: Déjà Vu or Unfinished Business? An essay investigating the connections between private property and policing over time. 

How I Became a Police Abolitionist Derecka Purnell argues that “When people dismiss abolitionists for not caring about victims or safety, they tend to forget that we are those victims, those survivors of violence.”

Eric Hobsbawm’s Century A look back at the ever-timely life’s work of the great marxist historian Eric Hobsbawm. 

Intercepted: The Revolutionary Life of Paul Robeson An interview with historian Gerald Horne on the revolutionary artistry and activism of the great Paul Robeson. 

A Doctor’s View from The Beleaguered Yemeni Port of Aden A sobering report on the many-faceted unfolding humanitarian disaster in war-torn Yemen.

Pankaj Mishra · Flailing States: Anglo-America Loses its Grip The critic and scholar Pankaj Mishra weighs in on the state of disarray and decay in the UK and US, further exposed by the Covid pandemic and its discontents. 

Abolition is Not a Suburb A reminder that the goal of abolition is not to recreate the deeply flawed and problematic suburban model of “stability”.

Trump’s Fascist Speech at Mount Rushmore A look at the worrying signals in Trump’s increasingly fascistic rhetoric. 

Fool’s Gold | Gene Seymour A critique of Spike Lee’s newest film.

Naomi Klein: We Must Not Return to the Status Quo. It Will be Even Worse Than Before The always on point Naomi Klein argues that returning to an even worse version of the pre-Covid status quo must be avoided at all costs. 

‘Defund the Police,’ ‘Cancel Rent’: The Left Remakes the World An exploration of how the new ideas and movements emerging from the Left are giving much needed hope for a different, more sustainable future in a time of darkness.

Yavne: A Jewish Case for Equality in Israel-Palestine Peter Beinart embraces a vision of a one-state solution in the Holy Land. 

Why Peter Beinart’s call for a one-state solution misses the mark A Palestinian response to what is overlooked in Beinart’s thesis on state for Jews and Palestinians.

The Unfolding Tragedy in Lebanon A haunting portrait of the famine and poverty stalking crisis-riddled Lebanon. 

Waste Away | Lina Mounzer An essay on the waste water problems in Beirut, and the insight they provide into Lebanon’s past turmoil. 

How Trump Is Helping Tycoons Exploit the Pandemic An investigation into the brazen rich-boy corruption and nepotism carried out by the Trump regime during the pandemic.

Rise up: the best books about the power of protest A book list highlighting titles that dive into the enduring power of protest and rebellion.

Pandemic Syllabus An in-depth syllabus to study the phenomena of pandemics from a variety of angles. 

Speculative Black Theatre History – AAIHS A short reflection on radical black theatre over the years. 

Climate change: what Antarctica’s ‘doomsday glacier’ means for the planet The headline says it all. The clock is ticking…

The Invention of the Police This New Yorker article asks: Why did American policing get so big, so fast? The answer, mainly, is slavery. 

Read to Resist: Weeks 14 & 15

This section of Call & Response started as Read in Place, a weekly (or bi weekly) reading list to inform and inspire through the months of shelter in place as the Coronavirus shook our world. While the virus has not gone away yet (socially distance and wear your masks, folks!) it has also exposed something that has long been with us: the inequality and systemic violence and discrimination rampant in the U.S. and beyond. And with the massive protests resulting from the murder by of George Floyd, and the state repression that followed nationwide, it is clear we are entering a key moment as an anti-racist uprising and a deadly pandemic coincide. So Read in Place will henceforth be known as Read to Resist. That is because we believe cultural resistance to the profound violence around us (economic, military, racial, sexual etc) is imperative. Context, analysis and critical thinking are key elements to resisting injustice, as is art that inspires, delights and pushes us towards empathy and the creation of new, more humane and sustainable models for our communities and environment. So whether you’re sheltering in place or marching in the streets; creating art or teaching; parenting or healing, we urge you to read up and spread knowledge and solidarity to those around you.

-C&R

Weeks 14 & 15:

Intercepted Podcast: The Rebellion Against Racial Capitalism A look into 45’s incompetent and dangerous presidency as it pertains to the US  economy

What Did Cedric Robinson Mean by Racial Capitalism? Examining the meaning of the term Racial Capitalism and the scholar who popularized it. 

Abolition Isn’t Only About Police What Abolition looks like beyond defunding the police state

Zapatistas: Lessons in community self-organisation in Mexico As the first attempt to abolish police are under way in the US, the Zapatistas in Mexico have  been experimenting with self-organisation for years.

Seeing Future Plagues A story about the indigenous Communities who predicted the pandemic 

Poet Eve Ewing Connects 1919 Chicago To Today’s Racial Unrest Eve Ewing, a poet, draws connections between the 1919 Chicago uprisings to the present

Collection: Black Liberation List for Young Readers A reading list for Young Readers centered on Black Liberation

When France extorted Haiti – the greatest heist in history What France did to the Haitian people after the Haitian Revolution is a particularly notorious examples of colonial theft and a prime case for reparations.

The Second Amendment was ratified to preserve slavery A look at the real reasons behind the Second Amendment and its connection to the enduring legacy of white supremacy.

Intercepted Podcast: Confederacy Inc. A wide-ranging interview with the great Robin D.G. Kelley

Examining the Wreckage The United States is on fire—the historic movements for Black lives have raised class consciousness to levels that we simply have not experienced in previous generations. 

‘Our ideology is our pain’: Notes of an Israeli Black Panther A look at civil rights struggles of Israel’s second-class Mizrahi citizens

On the Defensive: Navigating White Advantage and White Fragility A 2015 review by the eminent historian David Roediger of the book White Fragility 

‘If you take the land, you must give people citizenship’ A Palestinian response to Israel’s annexation plans..

Policing the World Since World War II, the United States has spread its style of policing—and police technology—around the world as a way to exert control.

Eugene V. Debs and the Endurance of Socialism Debs ran for President five times, captivating crowds by the tens of thousands and leaving behind a legacy of speaking truth to power.

Black AfterLives Matter A moving reflection on cultivating ‘Kinfulness’ as Reproductive Justice

Leo Tolstoy vs. the Police Why the great Russian novelist’s critique of state-sponsored violence bears thinking about now.

Correcting ‘Hamilton’ – Harvard Gazette A critique of the problematic racial politics and historical oversights of the hit musical Hamilton.

On John Coltrane’s “Alabama” The John Coltrane Quartet’s “Alabama” is a strange song, incongruous with the rest of the album on which it appears

Opinion | Trump Exploits the Pandemic to Deport Immigrant Children A searing critique of Trump’s inhumane immigration policies during the pandemic.

The Importance of Black Cinema and Supporting BIPOC Films – Arts + Culture

It’s no secret that the film industry is notoriously, overwhelmingly white.

Review + Interview: The Undocumented Americans by Karla Cornejo “A little bit Studs Terkel, a little bit Zora Neale Hurston, and a whole lotta Nirvana, Karla Cornejo belongs to the chorus of voices that compose The Undocumented Americans.”

You Should Have Been Listening to Octavia Butler This Whole Time The great Octavia Butler’s “Parable of the Sower” isn’t just a prescient dystopia—it’s a monument to the wisdom of Black women and girls.

Hold Prosecutors Accountable, Too In order to achieve lasting change, we must focus on systemic problems across the criminal justice system. That includes holding prosecutors accountable.

Hip-hop is the soundtrack to Black Lives Matter protests, continuing a tradition that dates back to the blues

Billions of children are being punished by the pandemic Historian Vijay Prashad turns to the hardships endured by children around the world during the Covid crisis.

Resistance Against Erasure: Talking With Marianne Chan Marianne Chan discusses her debut poetry collection, All The Heathens

American Fascism: It Has Happened Here | by Sarah Churchwell “When Americans think of dictators, they always think of some foreign model”

Why Are Some Journalists Afraid of “Moral Clarity”? A call for moral clarity in the face of totalitarianism and state violence, especially at home.

Bowman Taught Eliot Engel a Foreign Policy Lesson Jamal Bowman’s history over Democratic establishment man Eliot Engel was not just about NY, but about Palestine and beyond, and the sea change already afoot. 

From the NYT Magazine: ‘It Is Time for Reparations’ A call for reparations in the face of generational economic injustice.

An Essential Watchlist of Groundbreaking Black 

Documentaries

Decolonizing the vaccine A look at how Africans can lead the charge to decolonize the biomedical industry, especially as we wait for a vaccine.

Protests target Spanish colonial statues that ‘celebrate genocide’ in US west A report on the historical reckoning  with the colonial pasts of the Americas.

Palestinians are fighting to dismantle apartheid, not just annexation Why Israel’s illegal annexation is just the continuation of decades of U.S. backed theft of Palestinian land and sovreignty. 

Joe Biden Has Built a Career on Betraying Black Voters A searing examination of Joe Biden’s highly problematic legacy when it comes to race. 

There will be a One-State Solution Yusef Munayyer examines the inevitability of a one state solution in apartheid Israel. 

Read to Resist: Weeks 12 & 13

So whether you are sheltering in place or marching in the streets; creating art or teaching; parenting or healing, we urge you to read up and spread knowledge and solidarity to those around you.

Suggested Reading/Viewing/Listening  from C & R:

This section of Call & Response started as “Read in Place”, a weekly (or bi weekly) reading list meant to inform, inspire and entertain through the months of shelter in place as the Coronavirus shook our world. While the Coronavirus has not gone away yet (socially distance and wear your masks, folks!) it has also exposed something that has long been with us: the inequality and systemic violence and discrimination that runs rampant in the U.S. and beyond. And with the massive protests resulting from the Memorial Day murder by Minneapolis police of George Floyd and the fierce state repression that followed nationwide, it is clear we are entering a key moment as an anti-racist uprising and a deadly pandemic coincide. So while the content curated here will be much the same as before,  Read in Place will henceforth be known as Read to Resist. We believe cultural resistance to the profound violence around us (economic, military, racial, sexual etc) is imperative. Knowledge and context, analysis and critical thinking are key elements to resisting injustice, as is art that inspires, delights  and pushes us towards genuine empathy and the creation of new, more humane and sustainable models for our communities and environment. So whether you are sheltering in place or marching in the streets; creating art or teaching;  parenting or healing, we urge you to read up and spread knowledge and solidarity to those around you. 

-C&R

A protester poses for a portrait with his placard as he joins the global Black Lives Matter movement in Dakar, Senegal, on June 6, 2020. John Wessels / AFP / Getty

Weeks 12 & 13:

Images From a Worldwide Protest Movement

Opinion | America, This Is Your Chance

Intercepted Podcast: Ruth Wilson Gilmore on Abolition

An uprising comes from America’s viral underclass.

Toni Morrison, The Art of Fiction No. 134

The Fire This Time

Mariame Kaba: Everything Worthwhile Is Done With Other People

Opinion | Yes, We Mean Literally Abolish the Police

Poet Willie Perdomo on ‘Poetry as a Decolonial Practice

The Trayvon Generation’ by Elizabeth Alexander

“George Floyd,” by Terrance Hayes

Cornel West on US protests: The chickens have come home to roost

Be Realistic: Demand the Impossible

What Columbus Day really celebrates: The ‘most massive act of genocide’ in world history

In Defense of Destroying Property – The Nation

The Art of Distance No. 12 – Paris Review Interviews Six Black Writers. 

The Poems That Poets Turn to in Times of Strife – The New York Times 

Opinion | The End of Black Politics

Police: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)

A Political Philosophy of Self-Defense- Boston Review

Burning Down the 3rd Police Precinct Changed Everything –  The Nation

Dispatch from the Rebellion in Minneapolis

Abolishing Prisons Is within Our Grasp

Some Statues Are Like Barbed Wire – Boston Review

How to Design Justice Into America’s Cities

No Justice, No Peace

You Are Who I Love by Aracelis Girmay – Poems | poets.org

Harpers: [Complaints] No Biggie

Whose Grief? Our Grief

‘All lies’: how the US military covered up gunning down two journalists in Iraq

lRobin Kelley’s Reading List: ‘Back History in Three Acts’ – Boston Review

On the Minds of Black Lives Matter Protesters: A Racist Health System

The Labor Movement Faces A Reckoning Over Police Unions

Inside the Chicago Police Department’s secret budget

A Short History of US Law Enforcement Infiltrating Protests

Towards a global intifada | George Floyd protests

Notes on the George Floyd Protests in Minneapolis

Poem: Stay Safe by Luther Hughes | Poetry Magazine

The US, like Israel, is wielding the violence of an occupying power

Brazilian Artists Counter Bolsonaro’s Cultural Censorship With Cartoons

George Floyd protests: The fight for civil rights is never “nonviolent.”

Why climate change is a civil rights battle

Read to Resist: Weeks 10 & 11

This section of Call & Response started as “Read in Place”, a weekly (or bi weekly) reading list meant to inform and inspire through the months of shelter in place as the Coronavirus shook our world. While the Coronavirus has not gone away yet (socially distance and wear your masks, folks!) it has also exposed something that has long been with us: the inequality and systemic violence and discrimination that runs rampant in the U.S. and beyond. And with the massive protests resulting from the Memorial Day murder by Minneapolis police of George Floyd and the fierce state repression that followed nationwide, it is clear we are entering a key moment as an uprising and a pandemic coincide. So while the content curated here will be much the same as before,  Read in Place will henceforth be known as Read to Resist. We believe cultural resistance to the profound violence around us (economic, military, racial, sexual etc) is imperative. Knowledge and context, analysis and critical thinking are key elements to resisting injustice, as is art that inspires, delights  and pushes us towards genuine empathy and the creation of new, more humane and sustainable models for our communities and environment. So whether you are sheltering in place or marching in the streets; creating art or teaching;  parenting or healing, we urge you to read up and spread knowledge and solidarity to those around you. 

-C&R

Photo by Chris Machian/Omaha World-Herald via AP

Week 11 (curated with a focus on giving context to the current protests, Black Lives Matter and the ongoing fight against white supremacy):

AP PHOTOS: Images from protests across a traumatized nation

George Floyd Protests Show Rage And Anguish : The Picture Show

The Minneapolis Rebellion, According to the People Living It

Reading Towards Abolition: A Reading List on Policing, Rebellion, and the Criminalization of Blackness

Minneapolis: The Rise of the ‘Thumpers’

Opinion | How Western media would cover Minneapolis if it happened in another country

The answer to police violence is not ‘reform’. It’s defunding. Here’s why | Alex S Vitale

Teaching for Black Lives

Donald Trump’s Antifa Bogeyman Has a Long, Proud History of Fighting Fascists

As the George Floyd protests continue, let’s be clear where the violence is coming from | Rebecca Solnit

Opinion | Remember, No One Is Coming to Save Us

Even With Years of Complaints, Police Forces Are Slow to Change

Murder, Shootings, and Excessive Force: Tracking the String of Police Violence that led to CHP Plowing Through Protesters in LA

A Report from Occupied Territory (by James Baaldwin)

As the George Floyd protests continue, let’s be clear where the violence is coming from | Rebecca Solnit

FBI Investigated White Supremacists in Police

Malcolm and Martin | Esquire | APRIL 1972 (by James Baldwin)

The Minneapolis Uprising in Context

The Socialist Case Against the Police – Rampant

Where Do Many Police Departments Train? In Israel

The Only Solution Is to Defund the Police

7 Ways The Obama Administration Has Accelerated Police Militarization

Across America, police are responding to peaceful protests with violence | Nathan Robinson

The climate crisis is racist. The answer is anti-racism

Caught on camera, police explode in rage and violence across the US

George Floyd protests: Police erupt in violence nationwide during the third night of protests.

Opinion | The Women Behind White Power

Amid Minneapolis Uprising, Anti-War Veterans Call On National Guard to Stand Down

A Few Good Sadists – CounterPunch.org

How to Protest Safely in the Age of Surveillance

The Intolerable Tensions Between American Cities and their Police Forces

Don’t Fall for the Myth of the “Outside Agitator” in Racial Justice Protests

American violence in the time of coronavirus (Armed and contagious) — High Country News – Know the West

Their Minneapolis Restaurant Burned, but They Back the Protest

Who Exactly Is Doing the Looting, and Who’s Being Looted?

Minneapolis police leader defending George Floyd’s killers tied to ‘white power’-linked biker gang

HaymarketBooks.org

(1963) Malcolm X, “Message to the Grassroots” •

Destroying a police precinct is a reasonable response to unreasonable killings.

Perspective | This is why Colin Kaepernick took a knee

Far-Right Extremists Are Hoping to Turn the George Floyd Protests Into a New Civil War

Black Lives Matter: A Reading List To Help You Understand Systemic Racism Following The Death Of George Floyd

WEB Dubois, I Won’t Vote

Week 10: 

How jazz legend Archie Shepp, his nephew Raw Poetic and a cast of D.C. musicians teamed up for an experimental improvised album

The Trans Obituaries Project: Honoring the Trans Women of Color Lost in 2019

The Case Against Mars

Biden campaign removes some anti-Palestinian hate speech

Opinion | The ‘Liberal World Order’ Was Built With Blood

Eliot Weinberger · The American Virus · LRB 4 June 2020

What do alternative histories reveal about the present?

Intercepted Podcast: Trump’s Attack on Voting Rights and the Threat to Native Sovereignty

‘An Experience I Wouldn’t Wish My Worst Enemy to Undergo’

Cuba credits two drugs with slashing coronavirus death toll

What Parents Should Know About Coronavirus as Kids Return to Babysitters, Day Cares and Camps

Baghdad: A Walkthrough

Nobody Should Listen to Anything Rahm Emanuel Says

Hong Kong’s opposition unites with Washington hardliners to ‘preserve the US’s own political and economic interests’

López Obrador: Rebuilding the World After Covid-19

How the United States Government Failed to Prepare for the Global Pandemic

“Shoddy Implementation of Lockdown a Crime Against Humanity”

Black Americans are in an abusive relationship with the Democratic party | Derecka Purnell

Why are Africa’s coronavirus successes being overlooked? | Afua Hirsch

Seven of the best documentaries from the Arab world and how to watch them: from ‘For Sama’ to ‘Gaza Surf Club’

Read in Place: Weeks 8 & 9

As billions of people worldwide have had their lives upturned by the Coronavirus and as hundreds of millions are under shelter in place orders, many are turning towards reading, reflection (and bing streaming/listening) for sustenance.

Suggested Reading/Viewing/Listening  from C & R:
As billions of people worldwide have had their lives upturned by the Coronavirus and as hundreds of millions are under shelter in place orders, many are turning towards reading, reflection (and bing streaming/listening) for sustenance. So we at Call & Response and Pangea World Theater decided it would be worth curating and sharing some of the things we have come across worth diving into. So here it is, an eclectic selection of (mostly reading) materials to inspire, inform, entertain, and hopefully generate meaningful dialogue with those around you and those at a distance.

– C&R

By drawing essential workers, this artist asks how we take care of each other A beautiful collection of images of those folks that don’t have the privilege to stay at home and are making it possible for hundreds of millions of others to do so safely. 

You Don’t Need Invasive Tech for Successful Contact Tracing. Here’s How It Works. An examination of rolling out an efficient and effective contact tracing regime without the Black Mirror vibes.

From Black Death to fatal flu, past pandemics show why people on the margins suffer most The trends we see today are nothing new. The workers, the poor and the marginalized have always paid a higher price during periods of pestilence.

A Global Green New Deal: Into the Portal, Leave No one Behind An insightful conversation between Arundhati Roy and Naomi Klein.

Jared Kushner Had One Job: Solve America’s Supply Crisis. He Helped Private Companies Instead. Hint. He failed again. 

Rent Is Still Due in Kushnerville — ProPublica The widespread calls for lowering or cancelling rent during the pandemic have not been heeded by the Kushner real estate empire.

The Murderous Legacy of Cold War Anticommunism A new book reveals the cold and brutal calculus of Washington’s Cold War policies. 

Imagining a New Future A reflection on students reading African American literature during the pandemic. 

Naguib Mahfouz, The Art of Fiction No. 129 An archived conversation with the great Egyptian novelist and Nobel laureate Nguib Mahfouz.

At The Mercy Of The Courts We know that immigration is a tense topic in the U.S., especially since the 2016 election. What do the courts actually look like? How high are the stakes for those seeking asylum? NPR and Documented walk us through stories of immigration courts happening right now. 

The Jungle and the Pandemic: The Meat Industry, Coronavirus, and an Economy in Crisis The frightening realities of the meat industry and weak policy in the pandemic. 

“The Workers Are Being Sacrificed”: As Cases Mounted, Meatpacker JBS Kept People on Crowded Factory Floors This article draws our awareness to the increasingly widening wealth gap through the story of one family, affected by the spreading of coronavirus in their workplace. 

The Post-Corona World A look into the future and what we can expect when we know that our previous lives are never coming back? How do we build a future worth fighting for?

Pandemic Journal | by Coco Fusco Cubana artist and writer, Coco Fusco, along with a couple dozen or so other writers, takes us through the impacts of the global pandemic in their respective locations.

US Street Medics Look to Revolutionary Cuba for Lessons Amid Crisis Cuba, who 20 years earlier survived Peak Oil and, has had a preventative response to the pandemic. This has led to a very low death count and some inspiring models of solidarity and socialism in the island nation.

Perspective | The answer to the media industry’s woes? Publicly owned newspapers. This article makes a case for shifting the collapsing newspaper industry to a public owned model.

We Can’t Comprehend This Much Sorrow A day by day reflection on the present history being made during the pandemic, with an emphasis on grief and despair- even the hope that presents itself with overwhelming loss. 

A very dangerous government A quick study on the bizarre and brazen 35th government of Israel as it focuses on annexation of occupied Palestinian territories.

Espionage or Journalism? After the Snowden NSA Leaks A window into the life of American Journalist and Snowden collaborator Barton Gellman and the dangers of surveillance.

The Twilight of the Iranian Revolution The story of the context of COVID-19’s arrival in Iran and the repercussions of the virus in the short and long-term.

Naomi Klein: How big tech plans to profit from the pandemic Climate activist Naomi Klien leads us through the plans tech companies plan to profit off the pandemic

The UK government was ready for this pandemic. Until it sabotaged its own system | George Monbiot The shortcoming and missteps to the UK’s COVID-19  response.

Chicago’s Unemployed Rebellion – Rampant A brief history of the Chicago unemployment organizing and its lessons.

Xi Vows China Will Share Vaccine and Gives WHO Full Backing The future of medical information sharing and the international cooperation needed to survive this pandemic

Vijay Prashad on the CoronaShock Imposed Planetary General Strike An interview of Vijay Prashad, Indian historian and journalist, on “Coronashock” and state response to the pandemic.

100,000 crew members stuck on cruise ships after COVID-19 shutdown The scandalous and under-reported story of the lives of thousands of cruise industry crew members stuck at sea- without paychecks or accommodations.

We’re Not All In It Together “COVID-19 serves as a stark reminder of America’s deep, far-reaching economic and race-based inequalities”

“Black Capitalism” From Richard Nixon to Joe Biden Biden reveals a plan toward racial equity- but it proves to be antiquated and keeps capitalism at the forefront of the story.

How Does One Tell the Story of Asian America Jane HU shares vulnerable words about solidarity and identity through her examination of Minor Feelings: An Asain American Reckoning – a new book by Cathy Park Hong 

From crisis to crisis – Why protesters firebomb banks in Lebanon | Middle East & Africa The pandemic induced economic crisis, in Lebanon and beyond. 

For Palestinian rights movement, Biden poses a familiar quandary Palestinian activists have little reason to believe Biden will change his extreme pro-Israel stance, but that’s no reason to give up the fight. 

Free streamings and showings of contemporary Arabic cinema.

A High-Tech Coronavirus Dystopia An in-depth look into Pandemic Shock Doctrine and what some experts like Naomi Klein are calling the Screen New Deal.

Fuck the Bread. The Bread Is Over. Sabrina Orah Mark’s column, Happily, focuses on fairy tales and motherhood. You just have to read it to understand it.

Mike Davis: C’est La Lutte Finale A look forward at the global political economy of COVID-19 by the ever-sharp Mike Davis.

Read in Place: Week 7

An eclectic selection of (mostly reading) materials to inspire, inform, entertain, and hopefully generate meaningful dialogue with those around you and those at a distance.

Suggested Reading/Viewing/Listening  from C & R:


As billions of people worldwide have had their lives upturned by the Coronavirus and as hundreds of millions are under shelter in place orders, many are turning towards reading, reflection (and bing streaming/listening) for sustenance. So we at Call & Response and Pangea World Theater decided it would be worth curating and sharing some of the things we have come across worth diving into. So here it is, an eclectic selection of (mostly reading) materials to inspire, inform, entertain, and hopefully generate meaningful dialogue with those around you and those at a distance.

-C&R

Scenes From a Pandemic: 5

AP Week in Pictures, Middle East Stunning images from around the Middle East this week snapped by award-winning AP photographers.

Opinion | The Killing of Ahmaud Arbery Charles Blow contextualizes the wrongful death of Ahmaud Arbery within the Black Lives Matter movement.

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/26/us/ahmed-arbery-shooting-georgia.html?smtyp=cur&smid=tw-nytimes This article focuses on the Ahmaud Arbery’s murderers and the impunity they enjoyed for months after lynching the 25 year old.

Opinion | Legalize ‘Essential’ Coronavirus Workers Making a case to naturalize the undocumented workers who are helping get food to our tables

No More Fake Strikes Joe Burns gives us a history of striking in the USA and advises us on how to be successful as the strike re-emerges in the national consciousness.

How Obama-Era Economics Sold Us Short A deeper look into decisions President Obama made during the 2008 recession and the consequences of those decisions today. 

Chile’s Six Months of Struggle A look at the feminist-led mass protests in Chile and what looms for the one-time neoliberal “success story” of South America once the pandemic passes and the uprising continues. 

Los New Yorkers: Essential and Underprotected in the Pandemic’s… Giving insight to the lives of undocumented workers in the COVID-19 epicenter: New York City

https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/04/why-georgia-reopening-coronavirus-pandemic/610882/ The Atlantic investigates Georgia’s reopening and the sacrifice of workers and the service industry

Opinion | Democrats, It’s Time to Consider a Plan B A plea for the Democrats to make a back-up plan for this presidential election, especially given the allegations against the already shaky campaign of Joe Biden.

The 50 Best Movies on Netflix Right Now We’ve plucked out the 50 best films The New York Times lays out a list of some of the top flicks currently streaming on Netflix.

https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/20health/archive/2020/04/why-georgia-reopening-coronavirus-pandemic/610882/20/04/dont-wear-mask-yourself/610336/ We wear masks to protect others from ourselves, not the other way around.

Meet the indigenous artists creating their own comics industry Indigenous artists use humor and comics to assert their existence and as a form of cultural resistance.

The Israel-Palestine Conflict Isn’t a “Clash of Cultures.” It’s About Colonialism. A review of historian Rashid Khalidi’s new book The Hundred Years War on Palestine.

Not Persuasion, but Power A breakdown of higher education in the time of COVID-19 and the pre-existing conditions that plague universities.

Early Addition: Philosopher Explains Why Time Feels So Weird During The Pandemic An expert’s take on how we view and experience time differently during quarantine and global panic.

https://jacobinmag.com/2020/05/anti-colonialism-postcolonialism-worldmaking-global-south-postwar-nkrumah-nyerere The ‘worldmaking’ vision of anti-colonialists. 

The NFL Is Now Part of Trump’s Reelection Project As the NFL plans to reopen, Dave Zirin reflects on the usage of the NFL as a tool for the Republicans in the upcoming election.

As China goes global, its banks are coming out, too The rise of Chinese banks, and the threat it poses to Europe in decline.

The View from Latin America A look from across Latin@ America and the effects of the 2016 election.

Henry A. Giroux: It Is Impossible to Be Radical Without Being Optimistic An in-depth interview with the philosopher, educator and public intellectual Henry Giroux.

Green Jobs Are the Answer to the Coronavirus Recession The climate case for making the government the employer of last resort.

Just Another Indian Dead

Murielle Borst Tarrant is an author, playwright, director, producer, cultural artist, educator, and human rights activist.

Murielle Borst Tarrant is an author, playwright, director, producer, cultural artist, educator, and human rights activist. Author of the fantasy series The Star Medicine, she studied at HB STUDIOS in New York City, studied and interned with Spiderwoman Theatre, and is also a graduate of Long Island University. She works on the deconstructing of methods of the arts in Native communities in urban areas across the country, Canada, and in the NYC education system. She also consults with many urban and non-urban universities on the development of Native theater programming. Nominated for the Rockefeller grant in 2001, she won a Native Heart Award, and was the only Native American Woman to be selected by the Olympic Games in Sydney, Australia at the Sydney Opera House for her one-woman show, More than Feathers and Beads. She served as the Special Assistant and Liaison to Tonya Gonnella Frichner, the North American Regional Representative to the United Nations’ Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues, and served as Chairwoman for the Woman’s Caucus for North America 2013 to May 2014. Murielle directed Muriel Miguel, founder of Spiderwoman Theater in Red Mother, nationally and internationally, and was the Keynote Speaker for the Indigenous Women’s Symposium at Trent University. She was recently selected to speak on “Repetition, Tradition and Change: Native oral history and contemporary art practice in hostel post-colonial times” at the International Conference at the Muthesius Academy of Art in Kiel, Germany and the Norwegian Theater Academy. Named in American Theater Magazine as one of the most influential women in American Theater. She is the Artist Director of Safe Harbor Indigenous Collective and consultant for LaMaMa Experimental Theatre Indigenous Initiative. She has recently produced, written and directed Don’t Feed the Indians—A Divine Comedy Pageant! At LaMaMa Theatre.

We are the footnote, the Americana, the mystical, the noble savage, the November Indian heritage month, we are the “Oh yes that’s right” and always the other. We are the note at the end of the song that is never heard. We are the ones that fought your wars, gave you democracy, gave you your suffrage movement, the land you stand on.  We serve this country that has abused us, stolen from us, taken our rights but yet when one of us dies it is… Just another Indian dead. The term used when colonizers first came to our shores, after a massacre, after the very first epidemic, always listed as just another Indian dead.

 The sun goes down tonight in this city that I love with its manufactured canyons of concrete,  landscapes of steel, the glow of the river as the sun hits the peaks of the city mountains. As I watch that spectacular background while the sun cascades into the horizon and look at the water of the Hudson River, the darkness captures my soul and I realize tonight was just another Indian dead.  

We will look at a body for the last time tomorrow with gloves and masks on. We will mourn from afar because we cannot touch for comfort, hoping to see the sorrow with each other. Giving solace as best as we can to these daughters and grandchildren that are left behind. But there will be no reporters there to see this family grieve.  They will not be seen on television because we are the invisible, after all it is,  just another Indian dead. Our communities are being devastated by this virus as we speak but yet among all of this diversity, all of this inclusion, all of this equal equity, we are still not talked about or seen on television for the benefit concerts and the reporting specials. It after all is still, just another Indian dead.     

 We will talk about this virus and see the raging toll it has made but the real virus, the real epidemic will always be the invisibility that we endure, the invisibility that puts us in the shadows, the invisibility that makes us vulnerable, the invisibility that lets us know that we don’t exist to the world. The invisibility that not only make us the one of the highest risks because of health issues that are never really talked about. We remain the hidden in the shadows, where we can be destroyed and where we will be, just another Indian dead.   

 At the end of this week two daughters and a grandchild must figure out how to maintain their sorrow so they can go on and try not to be invisible in the chaos of burying a mother. They will now belong to that special club that none of us want to be part of and that is saying goodbye to a mother and grandmother.  They will no longer look at the sky the same, hear a song with the same joy or watch a sunset without feeling grief. Many will remember this time in history and know that they got through it but they, will not. They will only remember losing their mother. A grandchild will only remember losing her grandmother. She will no longer feel that touch of a grandmother’s kiss, that unconditional understanding smile that a grandmother has, that certain shine of joy when she walks in the room. To our grandmothers we are their memory and legacy just because we were born to be their grandchild. For these young women she will be the voice not heard ever again, the laughter silenced, a human being torn from the earth and the song on mute. She will be more than, just another Indian dead.  How many grandmothers have to die? How many language keepers must we lose? How many song keepers must be gone? How many more statistics do we have to have before we are visible  enough to the world outside of our communities so it can no longer be, Just Another Indian Dead!  

 The wind howls and sings tonight in the city streets, against the window panes while the dark entity that is this pandemic sails through and slices love ones. Tonight in the wind I hear the sound of those that came before me that prayed and warned of these hard luck times as my own grandmother called it.   I go to prepare for the morning, I think of my grandmother as I listen to the silence of the darkness outside of my window. I remember when she told me about the past and what has happened to us as a people, our family,  the hard luck times when an epidemic almost killed her entire family.  In our DNA we remember when this has happened to us so many times, the lost number of death, we are reliving it once again, remembering in the splinter of our minds when we had to bury our dead alone because there was no one left to stand with us.

  A mother and grandmother will be taken to her homeland this week, she will be flown out to go back to that place to rest with her ancestors in the land she longed for in North Dakota. You will not see her name in the newspaper or this Sunday’s special pandemic edition.  You will not see her face on television as a causality of this virus. She will not be talked about in the mainstream media. She with many other Native Peoples who will be buried this week are invisible.  She will remain in the memory of her daughters and grandchildren that loved her, she will not fade to them, she will not be invisible to them and she never was. She was a human being that lived and loved and tried to keep her head above water for her daughters and grandchildren.  She will not be forgotten to them.  But for the rest of the world that did not know her? Will she be listed with the millions who have perished before her, 500 years ago? Let’s hope and pray that she and many others that leave us during this hard luck time, who will not be listed or remembered in history as, just another Indian dead.   

This is dedicated to Victoria Yellow Wolf Tarrant, Tyree Giruoux and to all our brothers and sisters across these Native lands who are longer with us. 

Read in Place: Week 6

An eclectic selection of (mostly reading) materials to inspire, inform, entertain, and hopefully generate meaningful dialogue with those around you and those at a distance.

As billions of people worldwide have had their lives upturned by the Coronavirus and as hundreds of millions are under shelter in place orders, many are turning towards reading, reflection (and bing streaming/listening) for sustenance. So we at Call & Response and Pangea World Theater decided it would be worth curating and sharing some of the things we have come across worth diving into. So here it is, an eclectic selection of (mostly reading) materials to inspire, inform, entertain, and hopefully generate meaningful dialogue with those around you and those at a distance. 

-C&R

Palestinian chef Joudie Kalla shares what she’s cooking while sheltering in place Kalla, a Palestinian chef & author living in the UK, reflects on what cooking looks like during quarantine. 

Largest Rent Strike in Nearly a Century Amid Coronavirus Crisis With millions unable to pay rent, the state of New York faces the biggest rent strike in modern history. 

Anger and the Politics of the Oppressed Philosophers and social scientists weigh in on the morality of anger and the connection between anger and injustice.

Food is power As we prepare for inevitable food shortages due to the global pandemic, Joe Kobuthi reveals the ways in which imperialism has impacted food production- historically and at present. 

Seattle’s Leaders Let Scientists Take the Lead. New York’s Did Not Charles Duhigg lays out the differences between the East and West Coast government responses to COVID-19.

The Day a Native American Tribe Drove the KKK Out of Town Recovered history shows the way Native American’s stood up to white supremacy in 1950’s North Carolina and won.

Quarantine culture picks from Israel-Palestine and the Middle East +972 Magazine curates a list of worth-watching film from Palestine/ Israel.

One Rich N.Y. Hospital Got Warren Buffett’s Help. This One Got Duct Tape. This article exposes some of the gross inequities of the US healthcare system using New York  hospitals, overrun with COVID-19, as a case study. 

Libya turning into ‘experimental field’ for arms as war heats up -UN Reuters reports on the escalating proxy war in Libya, and the degree to which it has become a tragic and macabre laboratory for the arms industry.

The Rich and the Plague, Then and Now. A medievalist highlights the ways class status play an important role in our response to pandemics, past and present. 

Ecuador Is One of COVID-19’s Hardest-Hit Countries in the World Remezcla reports on Ecuador, one of Latin America’s  COVID-19 epicenters. 

Calling Healthcare Workers War “Heroes” Sets Them Up to Be Sacrificed This article challenges the tendency to idolize healthcare workers instead of giving them the safe working conditions they need and deserve.

The Coronavirus and the Future of Big Tech An interview with Margrethe Vestager, the Commissioner for Competition leading the European Union’s antitrust division, on the pandemic and big tech..

Midnight On The Clock Of The World – An Interview with Robin DG Kelley An interview with Robin Kelley, renown American historian, reflecting on the future of capitalism, jazz, and solidarity during the pandemic. 

[Letter from Washington] No Joe! A reflection on the troubling legacy of Joe Biden, presumptive Democratic nominee. 

“Solidarity Is Not a Market Exchange”: An Interview with Robin D. G. Kelley Another interview with Robin D.G. Kelley that goes deeper into his studies of Thelonius Monk, on solidarity, and Marxism. 

We Need a Multiracial, Working-Class Alignment A case for moving our movement efforts away from neoliberalism and toward a solidarity and equity based system.

‘COVID-19 kills in many ways’: The suicide crisis facing health-care workers A heartbreaking report on the result of stress and danger health-care workers are facing during this pandemic

Intercepted Podcast: Viral Injustice The Intercept podcast discusses the USA’s response to the CoVID-19 pandemic

She Saw Trump Before We Did Kendzior’s new book Hiding in Plain Sight reveals the growing oppressive systems that made the Trump presidency a reality.  

Citizen DJ | Experiments | Work Citizen DJ, a project by Brian Foo invites the public to make hip hop music using the Library’s public audio and moving image collections. 

“Let’s dust off our imaginations”: In Conversation with Bill Ayers

Call & Response had a conversation with Will Ayers about imagination, Zoom, individualism, and much more.

William Ayers, formerly Distinguished Professor of Education and Senior University Scholar at the University of Illinois at Chicago (UIC) has written extensively about social justice and democracy, education and the cultural contexts of schooling, and teaching as an essentially intellectual, ethical, and political enterprise. His books include A Kind and Just Parent; Teaching toward Freedom; Fugitive Days: A Memoir; Public Enemy: Confessions of an American Dissident; On the Side of the Child; To Teach: The Journey, in Comics; and Demand the Impossible!

C&R: Kids are at home, classes are on zoom (at least in some cases) and parents and relatives are on full-time. There are of course a host of problems that arise from this, from issues of internet access or lack thereof, to hunger for those who get primary meals at schools, to dire economic hardship and abusive home environments. And from a schoolwork perspective, there is a lot of anxiety and pressure to keep schedules, hit ‘benchmarks’ etc. What is your immediate advice for parents of school aged kids right now, as well as to teachers and students themselves, as shelter in place looks poised to continue through the end of this school year?

BA: Breathe deeply. Stay calm. Pause. Rest. Think. Relax.

Trying to recreate the school experience—with its relentless competition, its standardization, its never-ending testing and grading and ranking, its continual sorting of winners from losers, its assumption that learning is linear and transactional, its separation of life into disciplines and subject matters—at home would be a terrible mistake. Much better to rethink the school (when we finally return) along lines of what makes up a re-invented, functioning family. After all a dramatically extended family, at its evolving best, can be a small-scale model of a mini-society driven by norms of equality and reciprocity, a sense of shared community in which people care about one another and grow and develop together, mutual respect, recognition of differences including distinct capacities and interests and needs, shared wealth, attempts to account for and correct all chance/accidental disadvantages, and so on—from each according to their capacity and ability, and to each according to their need. That’s it: a wild but in some sense universal “family,” imperfect to be sure, a little off-kilter and slightly dysfunctional by definition, and yet at its best a model of everyday anarchy and common-sense socialism.

And we would all do well to remember that in our hurry-up, go-fast, get-ahead and oh-so-frantic world, the growth of a child is slow. Young children need encouragement and support and vast opportunities as they deploy all five senses in their journey through the kitchen, the apartment, the street, the world; older children need sustenance and understanding as they branch out, stretch, ask the big questions, interrogate the universe, and create an identity of their own—their rule is to reach. The universal theme of adolescence, captured perfectly by the great poet Gwendolyn Brooks, is this: I shall create./If not a note, a hole./If not an overture, a desecration.

So let’s shelter-in-place, yes, and let’s bake bread and make dinners together, invent games and songs, write a daily journal and illustrate every page. Compose music. Sing. Dance together. Exercise for an hour a day. Let’s write a group poem, every person adding a line that must contain a color, a food, and an animal; or write other poems in which each line begins with the same phrase, like “I wish…” or “This is the year that…” Let’s create an Oral History archive for our family, and our friends. What are we? Where do we come from? What’s your story? Where are we going? What might we be inspired to create?

Finally, don’t trust Zoom.

Yes, OK, I’m teaching my classes on Zoom (frown emoji).

It’s weird for me, but I’ve got it (I think) and, against my will and better judgment, I feel a little thrill and a burst of relief each time class ends without the internet exploding. I  push all the right buttons, issue all the appropriate commands. Oh, joy! (smile emoji).

So here we are, suddenly, all of us: distance learning, e-learning, online teaching, virtual classrooms—the whole bewildering turmoil. I soldier on, necessarily but not happily, all the while with an irritating chorus of cheerleaders in the background pushing me forward: “online learning is an excellent way to increase student engagement and differentiate instruction;” “digital tools save time and do the heavy lifting by providing ready-to-use lesson plans, instructional materials, and assessments;” “distance learning can continue delivering instruction without disruption even in events like snow days or the COVID-19 pandemic.” Every line offends what I know to be true about teaching, and my sense of what it can achieve, but, wow! snow days or COVID-19—that pretty much covers the waterfront; wait! better add floods and fires and extreme weather.

I was particularly annoyed when I saw my neighbor Arne Duncan, former Secretary of Education, on TV finding, as always, a silver lining in the catastrophe (after Katrina, you may remember, he famously declared that New Orleans was now liberated to create a whole new school system from  scratch!), this time ushering in the pandemic as dress rehearsal for the “classrooms of the future.”

Come on, Arne— Zoom is not the future of classroom life or teaching. In fact, that response betrays a staggering ignorance about the nature of each. When I saw Arne jogging while on my walk the other day, I suppressed the desire to strangle him, and, fortunately, remembered that  I couldn’t get closer than six-feet.

A colleague with experience in distance learning told me that on-line classes are to actual classrooms what frozen pizza is to home-made pizza: similar ingredients but a vastly different experience. Staying with the metaphor, pizza delivered is straight-forward and concrete, as well as often delicious; real classrooms can be delicious as well, but not because the teacher/pizza person “delivered instruction.” Teachers might write books and record lectures—I’ve done both—and those can be more-or-less delivered into the waiting hands (pizza-style) and upturned heads of hungry consumers. 

Classroom teaching at its best is quite different—it’s a relationship (again, like a family), a transformative journey for everyone involved. That’s why good teachers come to class ready to teach, but also primed to see, to hear, and to know their students as three-dimensional creatures, much like themselves, each the one-of-one, each a member of the group—an intimate encounter that cannot adequately take place at a distance. The teacher comes as a student-of-the-students, prepared to change lives, and simultaneously prepared to be changed by the propulsive, life-altering energy that’s released whenever a human being’s mind expands or rearranges itself. 

C&R: This moment is clearly one in which the inequities and, frankly, the brutalities, of the system we live in (in the U.S. but in much of the world too) have come into sharp relief. In an ideal world this feels like such a good moment to re-think and revolutionize the way we do everything, from healthcare to the environment, to war, peace and education. Starting with the education system, how  could we be using this moment to re-think and re-start our approach to teaching and learning and schooling for the long haul. 

BA: When we feel ourselves shackled, bound, and gagged or when we are badly beaten down, struggling just to survive, or when we’re frightened and unsure, living with dust in our mouths, the horizons of our hope can become lowered, sometimes fatally, and asking foundational questions can seem idle and silly. When no alternatives are apparent or available, action seems pointless. We all live in our time and place, immersed in what is; imagining a scene different from what’s immediately before us requires a combination of somethings: seeds, surely, desire, yes, necessity and desperation at times, and at other times a willingness to dance out on a limb without a safety net—no guarantees.

So let’s dust off our imaginations and dance out on that limb: What kind of world do we want to inhabit? We’ll get through this year in school without the SATs, so why not abolish those tests? And let’s abolish numerical grades. And detention halls and expulsions and suspensions and police in the schools. What else?

Let’s double the number of classrooms in the country within five years. Class size should be capped at 15 students—what privileged private school kids already have—and teacher pay should be pegged to the pay of members of Congress. With smaller classes and adequate pay, teachers will do a better job; students will get more attention; and everyone will move forward in a positive way with more space. 

The coronavirus is a most illuminating bug, and here are some of the shabby policies that had become part of our taken-for-granted world, and, therefore, we didn’t even notice until now:

~~Chicago Public Schools announced in February that they would provide soap in every school bathroom! There was no soap?

~~The New York MTA said that subway cars will be thoroughly cleaned every 3 days!

~~Detroit officials decided to restore water to homes of poor people whose water had been cut off because of unpaid bills!

~~Amazon told sick workers that they will not be docked for staying home and missing a shift!

~~Uber and Lyft will pay sick-leave for workers out with coronavirus!

~~The US Treasury Department said it will lift some sanctions on humanitarian supplies sent to Iran, the country with the third largest outbreak of coronavirus!

~~Big insurance companies announced (with fanfare) that they will waive co-pays for people with coronavirus!

~~The national shame and horror of mass incarceration meets the pandemic, and every minor crime/punishment becomes a potential death sentence!

~~The federal government is considering proposals that amount to Medicare for All With Coronavirus! Socialist medicine, but for only that one illness.

If you’re not pissed off about all of this, you’re not paying attention.

This is a time to get clear, really clear, and rise up.

Jack Halberstam’s brilliant book, The Queer Art of Failure, offers an essential insight for these terrible times: when things are “normal”—predictable, common-place, habitual—he argues, whether in one’s personal relationships, one’s work life, or one’s politics, life putt-putts along at an expected pace with little fanfare, and without much need for thought or reflection. The dogma of common sense is firmly set to “normal.” But if an unanticipated fracture occurs—one’s partner has an affair, one gets laid off or furloughed, Donald Trump becomes president—the rupture is palpable, and it’s suddenly time to question everything, challenge the taken-for-granted, rethink basic assumptions, reimagine and rebuild.

This is just such a time.

Of course I know as much about the novel coronavirus as any other dazed participant-observer—more than Donald Trump and Mike Pence combined, but that’s next to nothing.

I do know that the airlines are on life support, that SXSW was cancelled, that the NBA suspended the basketball season, that unemployment levels are staggering, that hunger worldwide is spiking, and that I can’t meet my classes in person. I know the illness is spreading exponentially, that official inaction wasted precious time at the start, and that a patch-work health care system (“the best in the world!” according to official messaging) and a hollowed out public medical administration has left the US flat-footed.

The ruling class—the powerful, the wealthy, the 1% and their enablers in the political class—has an agenda that’s aggressively promoted in good times and in bad, an agenda pulled quickly from the bottom drawer in any crisis and rushed relentlessly toward center stage. So here we are: the privatization of public goods and services, massive transfers of wealth from the public to the private, the destruction of participatory democracy and the erasure of the public, the suppression of voting, the reduction of education and health care and public safety to products, the intensification of white-supremacy, and more.

The perennial contradiction between “we” and “me”—a basic human tension with vast social, cultural, and political differences and dimensions—lurched violently toward an exclusive “ME” in our country in 1980 with the “Reagan Revolution” and its racist dog-whistles, its opposition to any concept of collectivity or the “public,” its weaponized individualism, and its anemic, libertarian definition of “freedom.” “Public safety” became “own a gun;” “public education” became a product to be bought at the market place; “public health” was reduced to “take care of yourself.” The word itself—“public”—in some contexts was racially coded: public welfare, public housing, public aid, public transportation. Saint Ronald Reagan, godhead of the Right and the icon to whom every Republican leader bends a knee and genuflects piously to this day, famously said this at his inauguration: “Government is not the solution to our problem, government is the problem.” That’s the dogma we’re now suffering together now, and that’s the orthodoxy under examination in seminar.

When at last we emerge from this particular catastrophe, what are we willing to fight for? What do we want?

As the ruling class weighs in on coronavirus it comes fully stoked with a predatory agenda—to take one example out of zillions: they are proposing a “payroll tax reduction,” which sounds nice, except that the plan amounts to stealing from and starving Social Security. In 5 years these same criminal bastards will say, “Social Security is broke! We must privatize the system (and let’s stay on message and call it reform!).”

To take another, the question of cost is constantly raised as people come to terms with the vast scope of the problem. Deborah Burger, president of National Nurses United, had a great response when she was challenged to explain how the US could afford to make a coronavirus vaccine free for everyone once it’s developed: “How insane and cruel is it to suggest that we have to figure out how to pay for it when we can actually go to war and not ask one question, but to prevent this kind of a disease, we have to say, ‘How can we pay for it?’”

We have (in the US) a mixed bag of private, for-profit health care provisions for individuals who can afford it, and rather shaky, wholly inadequate health coverage for people fortunate enough to have full-time jobs. Calling it a “system” is a stretch—a “system” implies at least a minimal structure if not some intelligible coherence. We have as well some limited and insufficient socialized medicine for veterans (the VA system), for the elderly (Medicare), and for the poor (Medicaid)—all under steady attack and relentless chipping away by Right-wing ideologues. Nowhere is there a sense of the common good—just individual needs and personal solutions.

But health equals wholeness. Without collective health, we have humanity shattered. Let’s use this time to mobilize and develop our own agenda. After all coronavirus is potentially instructive and educational, revealing more than concealing, but let’s draw the lessons explicitly. In a country characterized by mass incarceration, vast inequality, militarism, white supremacy, a crisis of homelessness and hunger, a political class refusing to face the imminent environmental collapse, and millions without health insurance, we need to get busy—and fast.

Let’s stop searching mindlessly for the much-discussed sweet spot that lies somewhere between fundamental structural change and the world as it is—a “revolution” versus the status quo ante, that long-ago time before Trump. Let’s see, is it here? No… Here? No… Maybe over there? Not over there either. Oh, wait, there it is: that mythological middle ground turns out to be the status quo itself!

Hyper-individualism and weaponized self-reliance is killing the planet, and it’s killing us. Yes, we are each sacred, each the one of one, but we are also each a tiny member of the larger group, a bit of the community, a part of the collective. We must rethink, and rebalance, the “me” and the “we” dialectic. When, 65 years ago, Jonas Salk, developer of the polio vaccine, was asked who owned the patent for his discovery, Salk said, “There is no patent. Could you patent the sun?” Health care, education, housing, food security are human rights—they are all about the “we.”

C&R: What about war? For a country essentially on permanent war footing, and as an imperial power with 800 bases worldwide, there must be direct and indirect lines between the business of war and the business of learning. But we rarely hear about it. Can you talk about those connections?

BA: Actually, the US has been at war for 234 of its 244 year existence. We are steeped in a culture of war, difficult to see, hard to resist.

Like every culture or subculture, the war culture hangs together with a complex set of shared meanings, webs of significance and common assumptions woven in such a way that members of the culture can communicate with and recognize one another. The war culture promotes a pervasive and growing common sense of American violence unleashed. 

The US spends more than a trillion dollars a year on war and preparation for war, more than the rest of the world combined. The war culture accepts that as a desire for peace. The US has military bases stretching across the globe, including a base in the Italian Alps, and yet there are no Italian air bases in the Catskills, for example. The war culture sees that as sensible and necessary. The war culture is everywhere, simply taken for granted, always lurking in the shadows and occasionally bursting forth and on full display. 

I remember a trailer for a film I saw in a theater several years ago—it looked dreadful, so I never saw the film, but it could well have been Mars Attack or The Day the Earth Stood Still—in which the repeating trope was an alien confronting a group of startled earthlings, saying in an eerily mechanical voice, “We come in peace”—just before blasting them into small pieces. It takes a minute for reality to catch up to these hapless earthlings, but eventually they get it. Like the challenge of the wandering spouse caught in the arms of a lover, the aliens hold to the classic defense, “Who are you going to believe, me or your own lying eyes?”

“We come in peace,” but wherever the United States puts down the boot, it brings more war, wider war, and a deeper commitment to war as the way. Marine Corps Major General Butler, two-time winner of the Congressional Medal of Honor, said in 1935 that, “War is a racket.” That was the title of a popular pamphlet he wrote, and a theme he elaborated in speeches through- out the country over many years: “It always has been. It is possibly the oldest, easily the most profitable, surely the most vicious. . . . It is the only one in which the profits are reckoned in dollars and the losses in lives.” Butler consistently urged citizens to demand the impossible and support three radical proposals: strictly limit all military forces to a defensive posture; hold a referendum of those who would be on the front lines before any military action is undertaken; and take the profit out of war by, among other measures, conscripting the captains of industry and finance as the foot soldiers in any impending fight.

A pervasive and frantically promoted proposition that runs loose in the land is that being a military powerhouse makes the United States (and people everywhere) safe, protects freedoms, and is a force for peace and democracy in a threatening, dangerous, and hostile world. It’s not true—not even close—but it has a huge and sticky hold on our imaginations. 

When random US politicians tell antiwar protestors picketing a town hall meeting, “It’s because of the sacrifices our troops are making in [fill in the blank: Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, Yemen, Libya, the “Middle East,” Korea, Panama, or wherever turns out to be next] that you have the freedom to stand here and speak out,” they’re tapping into that stuttering cliché. When a retired general speaks confidently at a televised congressional hearing, explaining to the credulous audience that the “enemy can be defeated” if only the Pentagon would be granted more funds to purchase more weapons, and then given greater leeway in their deployment and use, he’s issuing the same unexamined and banal truism. When the talking heads tell us it’s unfortunate that US economic strength rides on oil, a resource that “happens to come from a nasty neighborhood,” but it’s “a blessing” we have the power to police that part of the world, they’re doing the same thing. And when folks across the political spectrum express public gratitude and support for “our fighting men and women overseas,” while refusing to send their own children into those same wars or harboring serious private doubts about the wisdom, purpose, and execution of whatever US adventure is currently in play, they too are situated in that wide open field of received wisdom and diminishing options. 

What if we challenged these instances of hypocrisy and defensive dogma, and insisted that there are more honest and straightforward ways to support US military men and women? What if we demanded their immediate decommission and return home, and insisted that they be provided excellent medical and psychological care, good jobs, affordable housing, and the best available educational opportunities—the things every human being deserves? What if we spoke up in the face of that idiot politician and asked him to draw a straight line between free speech and the specific invasion he’s now supporting and explicitly (or at least implicitly) defending? What if we locked arms as we built a growing wave of peace advocates, anticipating and opposing the next aggression, and the next? What if the Department of Defense became the Department of Peace, and peace education became a core component of school learning?

The history of US military actions is a history of conquest and genocide from the start and chaos and catastrophe ever since: invading and occupying Vietnam and then intentionally expanding that war into neighboring Laos and Cambodia as retribution for the US de- feat, a disaster that cost the lives of six thousand people every week for ten years; unleashing a massive shock-and-awe attack on Iraq in 2003 that led to the breakup of that nation and the rise of several reactionary fundamentalist and terrorist formations including ISIS; orchestrating a fifty-year campaign to destabilize and topple the Cuban government; propping up nasty regimes from medieval Saudi Arabia to apartheid South Africa; overthrowing elected presidents in Iran in 1953, Guatemala in 1954, and Chile in 1973; instigating constant civil unrest in Venezuela for fourteen years including a successful if short-lived coup in 2002; supporting the communist purge and the genocide that followed in Indonesia in the mid-1960s; participating in the murders of the African freedom fighter Patrice Lumumba in Congo in 1961, the Moroccan anti-imperialist Mehdi Ben Barka in Paris in 1965, the internationalist Che Guevara in Bolivia 1967, and the anti-colonial leader Amílcar Cabral in Guinea-Bissau in 1973; exporting billions of dollars in arms to Israel, Turkey, and Saudi Arabia, and reactionary regimes and right-wing subversives the world around. As busy and ambitious as this looks, it’s only the tip of a menacing mega-iceberg, an emblematic list as opposed to an exhaustive survey. 

Justice and democracy do not belong to war; on the contrary, each is easily injured and quickly exterminated in its furnaces. John Dewey, the great philosopher of education, observed that in war all governments turn authoritarian and totalitarian. We can see the wreckage all around us: omnivorous national security and surveillance; the abrogation of privacy and civil liberties; the wide use of mass incarceration; the banality of torture, domestically and internationally; and the undermining of tolerance everywhere. Historically, law and rights yield in the face of war: Abraham Lincoln’s famous suspension of habeas corpus during the Civil War; the Palmer Raids following World War I; the mass arrests and incarceration of Japanese Americans during World War II; illegal imprisonment as policy today. These moves are all defended by the war-makers as necessary during wartime. 

The US entered new territory after 9/11, for we are in our twentieth year of a government-proclaimed state of permanent war, an absolute war against “terrorism” or “evil.” While there are indeed dreadful and desperate tactics being deployed everywhere—suicide bombings, hijackings, beheadings, random killings—the enemy remains vague and the target elusive: terrorists and “evildoers,” insurgents and radicals, the “worst of the worst” or the “bad actors.” Practically every politician in Washington notes casually that we are at war; it’s completely normalized. George W. Bush proudly called himself a “war president;” Barack Obama, too, chose to claim the mantle of the warrior; now Trump calls himself a “war president” fighting an “invisible enemy.” Whoever sits on the throne of American Empire wears the garments of the warmonger—unless and until we bring the power of a popular movement to bear down and end imperialism altogether. 

Imagine if every “known terrorist” were dead or in prison— now try to imagine the state announcing an end to airport searches and phone taps. It’s inconceivable. 

Ask one of our careless politicians how we will know if any given war is won, or what the benchmarks of success or failure might be, and they become speechless. For these are perpetual wars, wars without borders, without obvious or easily defined enemies, and without concrete objectives; we can only know they are over when our Dear Leaders tell us they’re over. Until then—and don’t hold your breath—your rights to free speech and association are suspended because the rulers want to keep you safe, and these measures, they assure us, are an unfortunate necessity of war. 

To hope for a world at peace and in balance, powered by love, joy, and justice, to insist that the citizens and residents of the US become a people among people (not a superior nor a chosen people) and that the country becomes a nation among nations (not some kind of crypto-fascist übernation) is to resist the logic and the reality of war, and to see, as well, the war culture itself as a site of resistance and transformation. It’s to break with the frame that acts as if war is natural and inevitable. It’s to do the hard work of making a vibrant and robust peace movement— connecting with the environmental activists, the immigrant rights forces, the Black Lives Matter upsurge, feminists, and the queer movement—organizing to close all US military bases abroad and to bring all troops home now, leaving no US military or paid mercenaries behind; compelling our government to sign all pending international treaties on nuclear disarmament; mobilizing to cut military spending by 10 percent a year for the next ten years, dedicating the savings to education and health; rallying to suspend and then abrogate all contracts between the US government and Halliburton, Lockheed Martin, and Northrop Grumman.

C&R: What role do the arts play in U.S. schools today? And what role could/should they ideally play in a young person’s education?

BA: The great Chicago poet Gwendolyn Brooks, winner of a Pulitzer Prize in the early 1950’s and later Poet Laureate of Illinois, asked in her “Dedication to Picasso, an homage to the great man and the huge sculpture that he gave the city, “Does man love art?” Her answer: “Man visits art but cringes. Art hurts. Art urges voyages.”

The voyages art demands lie at the very heart of our humanness: journeys in search of new solutions to old problems, explorations of spirit spaces and emotional landscapes, trips into the hidden meanings and elaborate schemes we construct to make our lives understandable and endurable, flights hooked on metaphor and analogy, wobbly rambles away from the cold reality of the world we inhabit—the world as such—into worlds that could be or should be standing just beyond the next horizon. These are the voyages that foreground the capacities and features that mark us as creatures of the imaginary, uniquely human beings. Invention, aspiration, self-consciousness, projection, desire, ingenuity, moral reflection and ethical action, courage and compassion and commitment—all of these and more are harvests of our imaginations. And our imaginations are encouraged, nourished, and fired with art. 

Every human being is endowed with the powerful and unique capacity to imagine—each an artist of their own life—and art unleashes our deep humanity. A robust engagement with the various arts is central and not peripheral to an education for a free people. Albert Einstein famously noted that, “Imagination is more important than knowledge. For knowledge is limited to all we now know and understand, while imagination embraces the entire world, and all there ever will be to know and understand.” Liberation and enlightenment are each a product of the arts.

But it’s also true that art hurts. The capacity to see the world as if it could be otherwise creates yearning and liberates desire—we are freed (or condemned) to run riot. Art—necessarily subversive, unruly, and disruptive—challenges the status quo simply by opening us up to consider the alternatives; suddenly the taken-for-granted and the given world become choices and no longer warrants or life (death?) sentences.

“Art is not chaste,” Picasso said. “Those ill-prepared should be allowed no contact with art. Art is dangerous. If it is chaste it is not art.” He was distinguishing pretty decorations and castles-in-the-clouds from the grit and grind, rough and tumble of art. He simultaneously reminds us that the aesthetic in education is the opposite of the anesthetic: anesthesia is a drug that puts us to sleep, while aesthetics is a treatment with the potential to awaken us again and again. 

The arts are too often small and marginalized in schools, and this is a gathering catastrophe, not only for students and teachers, but for our common future as well. 

The arts ought to be at the center and in every corner of an education for participation and democracy. We are, in spite of the existential feel of things and our own natural narcissism, finite beings plunging through an infinite space and gazing toward an expanding heaven. We are in the middle of things, and at the end of nothing—the unseen, the hidden, the mysterious, the invisible, the indefinite, the unfamiliar and the unknown, the unheard of and the forgotten are vast, while our various maps of the known world are limited, paltry, and, if history can act as a guide here, mostly castles-in-the-sky. Learning to question, to interrogate, to experiment, to wonder and to wander, to construct and create—this is the sturdiest foundation upon which to build an education of purpose for a free people.

Life begins in wonder, and so does art; and education too.

Watch a newborn—five minutes old and at her mother’s breast for the first time and already there are questions and explorations, a dialogue of discovery and surprise only just underway. Look at a toddler negotiating her apartment or a nearby park or the beach—all five senses are fully engaged, every discovery considered and touched and smelled and—oops!—into the mouth for a taste! And soon they are sorting and building, drawing on paper or walls if the materials are at hand, imagining stories and inventing words, and putting their hand prints on everything. Every kid comes to school a question mark and an exclamation point—her work after all is the construction not only of a life, but of an entire world.

Every school, every classroom, and every teacher must choose whether to support and aid in the construction of a life, whether to help unbolt the vitality of the world or to hide and represses it. Every teacher must decide whether to keep the questions and the passion alive—creating environments for exploration, for doing and making, for experimenting and hypothesizing and failing and succeeding—or to hammer the children into shape so that they leave her classroom, no longer as vital question marks or exclamation points, but as dull periods.

One of Paul Gauguin’s most bizarre and oddly engaging works is a vast canvas filled with quasi-religious symbolism and wild wanderings, its title scrawled across it in a fevered hand: Where do we come from? What are we? Where are we going? 

Art asks those kinds of questions. Education does too.

Kids are born and then come to school with questions: Who am I in the world? How did I get here? What are my chances and my choices?  

The arts allow youth to assemble tentative answers to these and other questions, and over time to develop more sophisticated and dynamic ones. The arts offer an invitation to become the agent of your own story, the author of your own life, or the actor in your own film as opposed to some anonymous walk-on in someone else’s worn out and clichéd script.

Author, actor, agent, composer—these roles allow youth to wield essential tools against propaganda, political agendas, dogma, and all manner of impositions and stereotypes. Art seeks honesty and authenticity, and that means it dives into contradiction, disagreements, silences, negation, denials, inconsistencies, confusion, challenges, turmoil, puzzlement, commotion, ambiguities, paradoxes, disputes, uncertainty, and every kind of muddle. That makes art an ally of critical and engaged and vibrant minds. Art enhances a sense of being fully human, a work-in-progress born into a going world.

Emily Dickinson asserted that “Art lights the slow fuse of possibility.” Yes! Art lights a fuse.

How did we get here, and where do we want to go?

What is our map of the known world, and how might things be otherwise?

What is our responsibility as world citizens to one another and to future generations? 

What kind of society do we want to inhabit? 

Who do we want to be as people?

What can we become? 

What positive and humanizing aspects of work and labor do we embrace?

What gives meaning to our lives?

What time is it on the clock of the world?

Diving into the wreckage and swimming as hard as we’re able toward a distant and indistinct shore, overcoming difficulties and re-imagining life’s possibilities along the way—this is the spirit youth, students, and teachers might bring to these questions.

Reflection, fantasy, theory, nightmares and dreams—all of this has animated human beings throughout the ages, demobilizing and challenging the given world, inviting us to leap into the unknown, to jump off the edge, to change our lives, to escape at times, and to move forward positively at other times. Imagination invites us to reanimate our minds once again, and to get busy in a project of creative repair.

Imagination, then, is more a “stance” than a “thing,” and engaging the imagination involves the dynamic work of mapping the world as such, and leaning toward a world that might be but is not yet. Most of us most of the time accept our lot-in-life as inevitable—for decades, generations, even centuries; when a revolution is in reach, when a lovelier life heaves into view, or when a possible world becomes somehow visible, the status quo becomes, suddenly, unendurable. We then reject the fixed and the stable, and begin to look at the world as if it could be otherwise.

There lies the critical work of reweaving our shared world.